{"source":"manifold","id":"sO9JwkVQFVlY7KWN4VfA","ticker":null,"slug":"will-there-be-a-year-before-2040-in","title":"Will there be a year, before 2040, in which *total* AI suffering outweighs total 2022 farmed animal suffering?","description":"Title too long, didn't fit: [Resolves to 2100 expert consensus]\n\nResolves to YES if it is the expert consensus in 2100 that \"more\" AI suffering happened in a rolling year before 2040 than total farmed animal suffering happened in 2022, NO if it is consensus that there had been no such year. \"More\" here is a placeholder for a future operationalization of the notion corresponding to the accepted framework of sentience and suffering in 2100; if no such operationalization which is judged to be in the spirit of this market exists by then, this market resolves to N/A.\n\nIf there is no expert consensus by 2100, then this market resolves to N/A.\n\nNote that this question refers to TOTAL suffering, not NET suffering or equivalent. So this question could resolve to YES even if AI systems are on net not-suffering (have more positive experiences than negative) and farmed animals are on net suffering, as long as AI systems experience more total suffering.\n\nIf it turns out that farmed animals are incapable of suffering (have no qualia or equivalent), then this market\n\n1) Resolves to YES if there is any suffering whatsoever in any AI system before 2040.\n\n2) Resolves to N/A if no AI system before 2040 turns out to be capable of suffering either.\n\nRelated markets:\n\n[markets]","image":"https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/mantic-markets.appspot.com/o/dream%2Fv01OODOJzI.png?alt=media&token=19419dcc-7478-4b31-95a0-0377a2215a41","icon":null,"active":true,"closed":false,"start_date":"2023-03-16T23:33:16.235000Z","end_date":"2099-12-31T22:59:00Z","closed_time":null,"volume":11178.627674544534,"volume_24hr":0.0,"volume_24h_change":null,"normalized_vol_24hr":null,"normalized_volume":32.6195182800293,"liquidity":1725.5,"open_interest":0.0,"categories":["Other"],"tags":[],"synthetic":true,"is_group":false,"group_key":null,"parent_event_id":null,"probability":0.211472,"spread":null,"top_outcome":"Will there be a year, before 2040, in which *total* AI suffering outweighs total 2022 farmed animal suffering?","top_outcome_probability":0.211472,"top_outcome_prob_24h_change":0.0,"top_outcome_volume_24h_change":0.0,"updated_at":"2026-06-03T06:46:47.573580Z","fetched_at":"2026-06-03T06:46:47.573580Z","added_at":null,"url":"https://manifold.markets/Lovre/will-there-be-a-year-before-2040-in","chart_24h":[0.211472,0.211472],"markets":[{"source":"manifold","id":"sO9JwkVQFVlY7KWN4VfA","event_id":"sO9JwkVQFVlY7KWN4VfA","slug":"will-there-be-a-year-before-2040-in","question":"Will there be a year, before 2040, in which *total* AI suffering outweighs total 2022 farmed animal suffering?","group_item_title":null,"description":"Title too long, didn't fit: [Resolves to 2100 expert consensus]\n\nResolves to YES if it is the expert consensus in 2100 that \"more\" AI suffering happened in a rolling year before 2040 than total farmed animal suffering happened in 2022, NO if it is consensus that there had been no such year. \"More\" here is a placeholder for a future operationalization of the notion corresponding to the accepted framework of sentience and suffering in 2100; if no such operationalization which is judged to be in the spirit of this market exists by then, this market resolves to N/A.\n\nIf there is no expert consensus by 2100, then this market resolves to N/A.\n\nNote that this question refers to TOTAL suffering, not NET suffering or equivalent. So this question could resolve to YES even if AI systems are on net not-suffering (have more positive experiences than negative) and farmed animals are on net suffering, as long as AI systems experience more total suffering.\n\nIf it turns out that farmed animals are incapable of suffering (have no qualia or equivalent), then this market\n\n1) Resolves to YES if there is any suffering whatsoever in any AI system before 2040.\n\n2) Resolves to N/A if no AI system before 2040 turns out to be capable of suffering either.\n\nRelated markets:\n\n[markets]","image":"https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/mantic-markets.appspot.com/o/dream%2Fv01OODOJzI.png?alt=media&token=19419dcc-7478-4b31-95a0-0377a2215a41","icon":null,"outcomes":["YES","NO"],"outcome_prices":[0.211472,0.788528],"probability":0.211472,"spread":null,"active":true,"closed":false,"start_date":"2023-03-16T23:33:16.235000Z","end_date":"2099-12-31T22:59:00Z","closed_time":null,"volume":11178.627674544534,"volume_24hr":0.0,"prob_24h_change":0.0,"volume_24h_change":0.0,"normalized_vol_24hr":null,"normalized_volume":32.6195182800293,"liquidity":1725.5,"categories":["Other"],"countries":[],"updated_at":"2026-06-10T03:37:20.483894Z","fetched_at":"2026-05-05T13:29:58.281893Z","added_at":null,"url":"https://manifold.markets/Lovre/will-there-be-a-year-before-2040-in","event_title":"Will there be a year, before 2040, in which *total* AI suffering outweighs total 2022 farmed animal suffering?","chart_24h":[0.211472,0.211472]}],"_meta":{"attribution":"pdata.world — aggregated prediction-market data across 8 platforms","canonical_url":"https://pdata.world/events/manifold/sO9JwkVQFVlY7KWN4VfA","as_of":"2026-06-10T19:11:50.124039Z","docs":"https://api.pdata.world/docs","cite_as":"According to pdata.world (tracking Manifold): \"Will there be a year, before 2040, in which *total* AI suffering outweighs total 2022 farmed animal suffering?\" — top market at 21% probability across 1 outcome","source_url":null}}